Author: Nancy, PANews
Recently, the development of MEME on Solana has been losing momentum, while BNB Chain has experienced a strong resurgence. The two ecosystems exhibit distinctly different paths and characteristics in the development of MEME culture. This article by PANews will analyze the differentiated competition between these two ecosystems from four dimensions: the core of MEME culture, construction logic, infrastructure development, and market timing.
Core of MEME Culture: Wild vs. Official
In a sense, Solana's MEME ecosystem leans towards a community-driven "wild" cultural melting pot. The MEME coins on Solana are characterized by strong community spontaneity, which does not entirely rely on the deliberate push of centralized forces but rather stems from the enthusiasm and creativity of community members.
The diverse types of MEMEs extend from traditional internet culture to crypto technology memes, showcasing the creative breadth and intrinsic depth of its ecosystem, as well as a certain grassroots vitality. Animal-themed MEMEs are the most recognizable type within the Solana ecosystem, quickly capturing community attention by combining animal imagery with humorous or absurd narratives. For example, the Bonk community, themed around dogs, represents a counterattack against centralized pressure; the Shiba Inu WIF, wearing a hat, is purely a spontaneous community creation; and POPCAT, originating from the internet celebrity Oatmeal's cat meme, continues to thrive on-chain due to the viral nature of internet culture. PolitiFi-type MEMEs closely tie to real political hotspots, blending satire and speculative attributes, with the community amplifying their influence through sharing and creating derivative content. For instance, TRUMP, created by Trump supporters, and the MEME coin PNUT, born from the New York squirrel incident, are seen as symbols of resistance against government overregulation. Celebrity-endorsed MEME coins like those associated with Musk and Trump form a "celebrity + community co-creation" communication model, where external impetus is injected while the community still amplifies their influence through spontaneous creation. Technical memes like LLM, Solana Killer, and TPS often attract developers and tech enthusiasts through technical discussions; internet culture memes like Fartcoin, BOME, and Gigachad feature strong visual impact and simple, easy-to-understand slogans, achieving viral growth through community-driven creation and dissemination.
In contrast to Solana's more "wild" character, BNB Chain's MEME culture relies more on celebrity effects and external impetus from the Binance platform, resembling a "processing factory" where creativity and dissemination paths are highly concentrated around Binance's core figures (mainly CZ and He Yi) and official narratives. While this model can create a surge in the short term, it clearly falls short of Solana in terms of diversity and cultural resilience. For example, TST originated from educational videos by the BNB Chain team, and its popularity is closely tied to the Binance brand's halo and the indirect influence of founder CZ; Mubarak benefits from the investment enthusiasm of the UAE sovereign fund MGX and CZ's support; BROCCOLI revolves around CZ's pet dog; and Binance Card stems from early construction cards by Binance itself.
Of course, while Solana co-founder Toly has also supported some MEMEs through retweets and likes, his personal influence pales in comparison to CZ, and the projects he favors represent a relatively small proportion of Solana's overall MEME ecosystem. In contrast, the CZ effect on BNB Chain is very pronounced; his strong appeal in the crypto circle can trigger a concentrated influx of funds and attention with each statement he makes.
Although this top-down model can quickly ignite interest by leveraging Binance's traffic base, it also limits the community's freedom of creative expression, making it less diverse and resilient than Solana. Nonetheless, there are community-driven MEMEs on BNB Chain, such as Cheems, Floki, and Babydoge, all of which attempt to replicate the successful path of the classic MEME coin DOGE.
MEME Construction Logic: Everyone Minting vs. Curated Alpha
Solana's MEME culture benefits from platforms like Pump.fun's "everyone minting" model, significantly lowering the threshold for token creation, allowing any idea to quickly transform into on-chain assets. This low-cost, high-efficiency mechanism greatly stimulates community creativity, further enriching the experimental nature and activity of the Solana MEME ecosystem.
However, the side effects of this model are also evident—project quality varies widely, with most MEMEs quickly losing value after short-term speculation, lacking long-term viability. The market is flooded with speculators chasing quick profits, while projects with genuine cultural value or community foundations often get drowned out in the noise, making it difficult to nurture a sustainable community ecosystem. Solana's MEMEs resemble an open creative marketplace where anyone can set up a stall, but the quality of the stalls varies greatly.
In contrast, BNB Chain's strategy in the MEME ecosystem is more cautious. For example, Four.meme provides low-threshold startup opportunities while establishing an ecological fund to support potential projects financially. Although this "curated rather than flooded" model somewhat limits grassroots creativity, it significantly enhances the stability and development potential of the ecosystem. Relatively speaking, BNB Chain resembles a threshold-based incubator, filtering out low-quality projects to provide a more reliable growth environment for the MEME ecosystem. This is also reflected in the rarity of rapid MEME scripts.
The substantial resource support from the Binance platform and the financial backing of BNB Chain are significant advantages for its MEME ecosystem. Binance has hundreds of millions of users globally, providing greater exposure opportunities for MEME tokens, and can quickly push projects to a wide audience through Binance's marketing capabilities (such as the Alpha program and official announcements). Recent innovative initiatives by Binance further strengthen this advantage. For instance, the Binance Alpha 2.0 beta, launched for certain countries/regions, is directly integrated into the Binance exchange, bridging the gap between CEX and DEX, providing higher liquidity, capital efficiency, and accessibility for tokens like MEME; a "full compensation for losses" activity for Binance Alpha trading users; and a six-month zero-fee trading activity launched by Binance Wallet further lowers participation costs, attracting more users to try MEME projects. Additionally, BNB Chain's $4.4 million permanent liquidity support plan, set to launch in early 2025, provides financial security for early projects. This dual support of funding and traffic is currently difficult for Solana's MEME ecosystem to match.
Infrastructure Development: Diverse Choices vs. Ongoing Construction
The rise of Solana as a core hub for MEME is closely tied to its efficient infrastructure. First, Solana has become the preferred platform for MEME development due to its excellent transaction processing speed and extremely low transaction costs. This characteristic not only perfectly matches the viral nature of MEME dissemination but is also inherently suitable for the "quick in and out" speculative culture of MEME coins, meeting the demands of high-frequency speculative trading. At the same time, Solana has built a full-chain ecosystem that provides seamless support for the creation and promotion of MEME projects, from DEXs (like Raydium, Jupiter, and Orca) to user-friendly wallets (like Phantom, Solflare, and OKX Wallet) to convenient launch and trading tools (like Pump.fun and Moonshot). Additionally, third-party tools further enrich its ecosystem, such as GMGN, Dexscreener, trading bots, and RugCheck, which significantly lower the participation threshold for users, allowing ordinary users to quickly navigate the MEME ecosystem.
In contrast, BNB Chain also has competitive technical performance, with its gas fees significantly lower than Ethereum's high-cost environment, providing an economic foundation for the development and trading of MEME projects. However, BNB Chain is somewhat lacking in innovation and the diversity of its tool ecosystem, with its infrastructure development being relatively conservative. Currently, BNB Chain's DEX trading ecosystem heavily relies on PancakeSwap as a single platform, lacking the diversified choices seen in Solana. Moreover, the recent surge in trading activity has also created a breeding ground for "sandwich" attacks on BNB Chain, particularly affecting some newly launched MEMEs with low liquidity, leading to losses for retail investors. Additionally, the completeness of its supporting infrastructure is insufficient, and the overall richness of the ecosystem and user experience still need improvement. Notably, there have been certain risks exposed in DEX trading security on BNB Chain, such as recent incidents where attackers exploited vulnerabilities in Four.meme to steal liquidity pool funds, which may undermine user confidence in its ecosystem.
Market Timing: Bottom Rebound vs. Major Decline and Fluctuation
Solana became a hotbed for MEME experimentation early on due to its high performance and low costs. Starting from the end of 2023, during a critical phase of the previous bear market's bottom rebound, market sentiment gradually warmed from its trough, and the phenomenon-level MEME projects that emerged early on Solana (such as Silly, BOME, etc.) created a strong demonstration effect, igniting community sentiment and attracting more developers, investors, and community members. At the same time, Solana fostered a community-driven culture, which not only enhanced user stickiness but also formed a strong sense of identity, further solidifying its market position. Although MEME coin ecosystems on other blockchains also developed during the same period, they failed to capture the rising tide as precisely as Solana and lacked similar cultural cohesion, making it difficult to compete.
In contrast, BNB Chain's trajectory in MEME development has been constrained by both market timing and the broader environment. Its rise occurred more during the later stages of the MEME coin bubble burst, when market enthusiasm had significantly cooled, and investors' interest in high-risk projects gradually waned. Although BNB Chain attracted a certain level of development activity due to support from the Binance ecosystem and the cooling of Solana, as well as the suspension of OKX DEX aggregator trading services, its MEME coin projects have not produced as many phenomenon-level success stories as Solana and lack many representative projects with large market capitalizations. This misalignment in timing has made it difficult for BNB Chain to replicate Solana's brilliance during the MEME craze. Furthermore, the overall market environment's weakness has exacerbated this disadvantage, leading to its community culture and market influence consistently lagging behind Solana.
Overall, while Solana has established a "moat" through its technological advantages and cultural core, it faces the risk of burnout due to excessive speculation and stability issues; BNB Chain, on the other hand, demonstrates potential for latecomer advantage through steady layout and external support, but its cultural depth and long-term appeal remain to be tested.
免责声明：本文章仅代表作者个人观点，不代表本平台的立场和观点。本文章仅供信息分享，不构成对任何人的任何投资建议。用户与作者之间的任何争议，与本平台无关。如网页中刊载的文章或图片涉及侵权，请提供相关的权利证明和身份证明发送邮件到support@aicoin.com，本平台相关工作人员将会进行核查。
