Video title: The Great Gold Scam
Video author: Tucker Carlson
Translation: Peggy, BlockBeats
Editor's note: Against the backdrop of rising inflation expectations and a weakening dollar, "investing in gold" is becoming a mainstream consensus again. Whether in media commentary or personal investment advice, gold is repeatedly emphasized as an effective tool against uncertainty.
But the problem is: when “buying gold” becomes a consensus, what truly determines the outcome is no longer just the asset itself, but what kind of gold you are buying and who you are buying it through.
This article compiles the investigative content from Tucker Carlson's recent program "The Great Gold Scam," and from a mechanistic perspective, the core of these scams is not complex:
The first step is to change the product's form. Sales companies do not sell standard gold bars, but instead launch "exclusively issued" commemorative coins, significantly marking up prices through concepts such as "limited quantities" and "collectible value," with premiums reaching as high as 90% or even 130%.
The second step is to control pricing and exit mechanisms. These coins are controlled in circulation and quoting by the sales company, where investors pay a high premium when buying, but can only recover close to the gold melt value when selling, thus completely locking in the price difference.
The third step is to leverage trust for distribution. The company collaborates with conservative media personalities and influencers to convert audiences into customers. Viewers make investment decisions based on long-established trust, while the media side earns significant profits through advertising and commission—some companies even spend nearly $20 million annually on channel promotions.
The experiences of the victims also reflect similar paths: some transferred their retirement accounts into gold out of a need for protection; some made judgments based on “program recommendations” or "trust from acquaintances"; others were influenced by historical experiences, believing in gold's value under extreme conditions. But once they entered this system, they faced the same result—high premium purchases, low price recoveries, and irretrievable asset losses.
From a regulatory perspective, this issue has long existed and is difficult to eradicate. Although agencies like the SEC and CFTC have repeatedly sued related companies, due to low industry entry barriers and fast personnel turnover, when one company collapses, the original team often quickly restructures and operates under a new name, forming a "whack-a-mole" cycle.
A judgment presented at the end of the program is worthy of note: there is nothing wrong with gold itself, the issue lies in how it is sold. When a standardized, publicly priced asset is packaged into a high-profit distribution system, the relationship between its price and value will be systematically distorted.
The following is the original text (reorganized for easier reading):
When Gold Becomes Consensus, a Business of "Harvesting Trust" Begins to Operate
Tucker Carlson (host):
In 2025, gold prices experienced explosive growth. In just one year, the price of one ounce of gold soared from $2700 to $4300, an increase of 62% within 12 months. Why did this happen? There are many reasons, but one of the most important factors is likely the weakening of the dollar. And for years, several heavyweight figures in conservative media have been predicting this. They knew it would happen long ago.
Mike Huckabee, host of the American conservative television commentary program Huckabee Today, promotes gold on his show, saying, "You hear me talk every night about how important it is to include gold in your asset allocation. Folks, inflation is unstoppable, stock market volatility is intensifying, and economic recession is almost inevitable. I have been doing business with Goldline for over 15 years."
For viewers, buying gold seems like a good deal, an obvious choice, but that is not the case. We spent months investigating the so-called "gold IRA industry system" and its relationship with conservative media, and what we found was shocking.
For huge returns, some of the most well-known conservative opinion leaders have for years directed audiences towards those companies that exploit their gold investments. In some cases, these companies are even blatant scams, with highly unreasonable terms and astonishing profit margins.
This system primarily targets the elderly, but these companies' marketing strategies are highly effective, attracting individuals from diverse backgrounds who end up losing millions of dollars. We interviewed victims and industry insiders. This is a massive gold scam.
Dale Whitaker: An Internal Perspective on the Mechanics of the Gold IRA Scam
High-Premium "Commemorative Coins"
My name is Dale Whitaker, I am an accountant and also the author and whistleblower of "Gold Graft." I worked at Augusta Precious Metals for roughly three and a half to four years. At first, I did not realize the problem, but then a client wanted to sell back 5000 coins. At that time, we would tell customers that our spread was 29%, which means future clients could sell back to us at the purchase price minus the spread, combined with market changes.
Dale Whitaker
But that was not the case, as the company had complete control over these coins and could manipulate prices at any time. Later, the CEO called me to raise the spread, thereby reducing the amount we paid to customers when repurchasing. At that moment, I realized something was seriously wrong.
In fact, over the past two decades, Americans (especially those in conservative groups), spurred by trusted media figures, have poured hundreds of millions of dollars into commemorative coins to hedge against market volatility.
The operation of this model is as follows: dealers sign exclusive distribution agreements with well-known mints, such as the Royal Canadian Mint, the Royal Mint, or the Perth Mint.
They request these mints to produce customized coins for them and gain exclusive sales rights in the U.S. Once the mints agree, the dealers pay the minting costs and premiums, then gain exclusive distribution rights for those coins in the U.S.
Theoretically, the value of these coins comes from the gold or silver they contain. Therefore, salespeople can persuade people to transfer retirement savings into a gold IRA.
However, unlike standard gold bars, the coins in this IRA system are exclusively controlled by the selling company. The company then significantly marks up these coins and tells customers that the price is reasonable because they are "unique collectibles."
These coins still technically fall under the category of precious metal bars, allowing them to be used in retirement accounts.
Many people wonder why the prices of these coins are marked up so drastically. Why are they so much more expensive than regular coins? The answer is simple: because they are issued in limited quantities, and only we can sell them.
On the surface, this seems like a "willing buyer, willing seller" transaction, but the reality is far from it. Many people trust these opinion leaders, thinking the companies they recommend are reliable. When they contact the company, the salespeople package themselves as "trustees," telling clients "this is better for your assets," even emphasizing their decades of experience. As ordinary investors, it's easy to think: Why wouldn't I trust them? It's actually like listening to stockbroker advice.
How Trust is Monetized
Tucker Carlson
This business model is effective because it builds on years of accumulated trust between conservative media and their audience, leveraging this trust to draw consumers into highly persuasive sales pitches.
These transaction terms are often ludicrous, with prices far exceeding the spot price on the open market (which you can even check in real-time on your phone). They also include a large number of hidden fees and commissions, and many company practices have prompted lawsuits.
One of the largest cases involved a company called Red Rock Secured, with claims amounting to $76 million. The company heads, Shane Johnson Kelly and Jeffrey Ward, were former sales staff at Augusta, who left feeling their income was insufficient.
According to federal regulators, Red Rock used intimidation tactics to persuade clients to transfer funds, including liquidating deferred tax retirement account funds to purchase precious metals. The SEC charged the company and its executives with fraud, claiming their markups on the sold coins were as high as 130%. Through this model, the defendants allegedly defrauded more than $50 million from at least 700 investors.
Dale Whitaker
In recent years, such cases have arisen in large numbers. The enforcement strength of the CFTC and SEC is indeed increasing, and there are also many private lawsuits from clients who realize they have been deceived. But the problem is that regulatory resources are limited, and they can only deal with issues in a "whack-a-mole" fashion: sue one company, it collapses, but the salespeople quickly start a new company, continuing to do the same thing.
Tucker Carlson
So far, this is indeed the case. These companies are very easy to set up. You just need to establish a partnership with a mint, advertise on conservative radio and Fox News, and pair it with a group of aggressive salespeople.
In 2011, prosecutors brought 19 criminal charges against Goldline International for selling overpriced coins, with endorsers including Fred Thompson, Dennis Miller, Mark Levine, Lars Larson, Michael Smerconish, Mike Huckabee, and Glenn Beck.
A conservative television program promotes, "I have been doing business with Goldline for over 15 years; for me, this is an unequivocal choice. I think they are the best company in the precious metals field."
Tucker Carlson
A congressional investigation found that Goldline's average markup was 90% above the melting value of the coins, meaning it was 90% higher than international market prices. Although the company has never admitted to wrongdoing, it ultimately paid $4.5 million to settle. After legal scrutiny, Goldline's employees moved on to Merit Financial, which similarly sold coins through telemarketing and advertised on Fox News.
Regulators would take down one company, and another would quickly emerge, and this vicious cycle would begin again.
And indeed, this is the case. Three years later, Merit was accused of participating in a "nationwide aggressive fraud scheme," defrauding consumers of tens of millions of dollars. After Merit collapsed, many salespeople moved to Augusta Precious Metals, the same company Whitaker used to work for. We reached out to Augusta for verification, and they claimed Whitaker's accusations were "false." However, they also acknowledged that the industry "is filled with many bad practitioners and scammers." The company stated that Whitaker was fired for incompetence and had not had any relationship with them for nearly 10 years. Notably, Augusta does not publicly disclose its coin prices on its official website.
From Hedging to Bankruptcy: How Victims are Gradually Drawn into the Trap
Dale Whitaker
The target audience of Augusta Precious Metals is conservative Christians over 50. This demographic often believes in a certain "apocalyptic" narrative—that the current fiat currency system will inevitably collapse, and people will return to barter, with gold and silver becoming mediums of exchange. The company leverages this point to precisely target specific groups and ultimately deceive them into relinquishing their life savings. In my view, this is almost a form of "public plunder."
Rob Leinbarger: A $200,000 Loss from Following Program Investment Advice
My name is Rob Leinbarger, and I consider myself a thorough conservative. I joined the Navy as a helicopter pilot after graduating in 1984. After retiring, I worked at Motorola, responsible for research and development projects. Gradually, I built up some savings and established my "retirement reserves." Until the pandemic hit, I began worrying about market risks, so I thought about withdrawing money from the market and looking for a "hedge asset," ultimately falling into this scam.
Rob Leinbarger
I transferred my 401k funds into gold investments through Birch Gold. I had been watching the War Room program and trusted the host, so I followed up with this decision.
WarRoom Host
The salespeople told me these were "high-end commemorative coins." I looked into it myself, and indeed, some high-purity gold coins traded at prices above spot price, so I believed their claims that "limited editions are more valuable" and "will outperform gold spot prices in the long run." But it turned out this was completely wrong—I paid over $1000 in premium for this.
Later, when I wanted to sell some of my assets, I was quoted at melt price. The account manager even told me that the market was experiencing an "inversion," that although gold prices were rising, many retirees were selling, and therefore, these commemorative coins had no value now; the previous premiums were essentially "sunk costs."
It wasn't until I truly grasped their pricing mechanism that I realized that almost everything they told me was misleading. I made this decision because I trusted conservative media, but they had been promoting these companies. I believed them, and now I just want to tell others: This is not merely a matter of "doing more research," but rather not trusting these people.
Host and Industry Insider Comments
Tucker Carlson
Leinbarger estimates that this purchase of commemorative coins has cost him over $200,000.
In fact, for thousands of years, humanity has traded precious metals (especially gold) to store value in times of economic uncertainty. The earliest coins appeared around 600 BC in Turkey. Gold has been mentioned in Egyptian hieroglyphs, the Code of Hammurabi, the Hebrew Bible, and Homer's epics. In the story of Christ’s birth, gold was also one of the gifts brought by the Three Wise Men.
In 1792, George Washington signed a bill establishing the U.S. Mint, authorizing the government to mint gold, silver, and copper coins. Seventy years later, Lincoln signed the Legal Tender Act, introducing paper currency, marking the first time the U.S. entered a fiat currency system. After experiencing severe inflation during the war and post-war deflation, President McKinley established the gold standard, linking the dollar to gold at $20.67 per ounce, requiring the Treasury to exchange paper currency for gold as needed. This system ended on April 5, 1933.
During the Great Depression, Roosevelt quickly issued an executive order prohibiting private ownership of gold and requiring people to exchange gold for currency at a fixed price with the Federal Reserve system. This was to expand the money supply, as the gold standard had become an obstacle. As public confidence in the banking system collapsed, people withdrew deposits, exchanging them for gold. Americans who refused to surrender their gold faced fines of up to $10,000 (equivalent to over $250,000 today) and potential imprisonment of up to 10 years.
The government even employed the Secret Service to enforce the law, with some high-profile cases making the news. For example, New York attorney Frederick Barber Campbell tried to withdraw 27 gold bars from his bank (worth about $3 million today) and was ultimately prosecuted. Although he was not convicted due to technical reasons, the gold was confiscated. There was also a San Francisco jeweler, Gus Farber, who was arrested for illegally selling coins.
In 1971, Nixon completely ended the gold standard, and the U.S. government no longer restricted gold ownership, but public demand for gold continued. Between 1925 and 2025, the dollar lost approximately 95% of its value, while the price of gold rose from $20 per ounce to over $4000. In 1974, President Ford signed a law that officially allowed Americans to legally own gold again.
However, this industry is nearly devoid of regulation. It's like trying to stop a gunshot wound with a Band-Aid; you cannot stop new companies from continuously emerging.
The Washington Post estimates that in the past decade, over 30 customers from 20 states have sued more than a dozen gold IRA companies; federal regulators have sued four companies, two of which were just in the past year. The charges include systematically charging investors prices up to three times the value of the coins.
Dale Whitaker
As a conservative, saying "there needs to be regulation" sounds a bit harsh, but it is true. The government must step up because those harmed are not just individuals, but their livelihoods and life savings. The current regulatory approach is like "whack-a-mole," which does not fundamentally resolve the problem.
Andrea McAvoy: 34% Exorbitant Commission
Andrea McAvoy
My name is Andrea McAvoy. I used to work in real estate, but now I mainly stay at home with my kids. I started investing in precious metals around 2015-2016. This was an IRA account I established before getting married, and it had essentially become a "sleeping account." At that time, I had a two-year-old child, had just given birth, and was pregnant again. I learned about Lear Capital while listening to a podcast.
I actually want to support the sponsors of the programs I usually listen to, or at least I would try to. This is kind of a "soft recommendation." It’s the same in the real estate industry, just like with a "friendly recommendation." You think, since they trust these people, I can trust them too. So rather than Googling a company myself, it might be better to try the one they are sponsoring. After all, you would assume they must have done some background check; they wouldn’t want to damage their reputation by supporting an unreliable sponsor.
But at that time, I made a wrong assumption. So I invested about $186,000 into gold and silver through the IRA. Those sales pitches… were indeed very well-crafted.
I am trying to recall how they communicated with me. The general message was that these coins might be the best choice for me because they typically provide a "buffer" during market downturns, not dropping as much as other assets; while during market upswings, they would accelerate significantly—looking back now, that obviously sounds too good to be true.
If you look at the contract, it states something like: commissions will be explained during the recorded call. This should have been a very obvious warning sign, but I didn’t realize it at the time.
I still clearly remember that day. I was on a recorded call, washing dishes, while my two-year-old was pulling at me. The water was running, the child was tugging at me, and while I was “shushing” him, I was trying to quietly listen to the recording. When you are making a very large investment decision, your attention is not where it should be. They said 34%. But I couldn’t hear it as 34%, I heard it as 4%. That sounded like a reasonable level for a big transaction.
That was in April 2024, and I was in my second trimester of pregnancy. The market was very hot at that time. I logged into my Equity Trust account and found that the $186,000 had dropped to around $100,000 or about $109,000. I was completely stunned, I felt like this couldn’t be true.
I contacted Lear Capital to find out why her assets hadn’t risen with the gold price. They said everything was normal, so I started frantically calculating and reviewing. I found that they charged not only a 35% commission but also an additional 25% premium or spread. This means my assets were actually worth around $120,000. Had I purchased standard gold bars, my assets should have been around $213,000.
At first, they tried to convince me to keep quiet about this matter. Later, I contacted the attorneys general of several states, submitted complaints, and constantly exposed them on social media.
It’s funny, the salesperson I was communicating with seemed to think they could just give me some money to keep me quiet, like offering me $10,000, to see if I would just drop it. He called me every day, leaving constant messages. I barely returned his calls, just emailing him to say: don’t contact me again unless you return my money.
They will use all sorts of rhetoric, saying you have no chance of winning, you agreed to this arrangement, you verbally accepted these commissions on the call. But you must insist: I do not accept, I do not acknowledge. You must find ways to bypass these statements—it is doable, and that’s what I did.
At the same time, I want to say, "Don’t trust anyone." You must do your own research. You must read the contract carefully. You must be clear about whom you’re paying. This is very important. You cannot simply believe others have your best interests at heart. You can't just listen to what some commentator says on TV or online and assume they're on your side. They are obviously working for their own gain. They will profit from the decision you are making through advertising, partnerships, and more.
Host and Industry Insider Comments
Tucker Carlson
If you check, you will find that Lear has great online reviews, and high ratings on the Better Business Bureau. But this is actually because, as a condition of a refund, Lear required me to leave a five-star review and indicate to the BBB that I was "satisfied" with the company’s handling of the outcome.
As a consumer of conservative media, I now ask myself: are these people truly considering my interests, or are they just trying to make money?
The answer is almost obvious—it’s money. In fact, when we started this channel, multiple gold companies actively reached out to us, one even offered nearly $20 million a year for collaboration.
At first, this sounded reasonable. We also value gold. But the problem is: a product that is publicly priced in the market, with very low profit margins, how could any company have such a large marketing budget? Now the answer is clear—they’re not selling "gold" as a product but running a high-profit business built around information asymmetry and trust. Essentially, this is harvest from consumers, especially targeting those who are more easily trusting of media and opinion leaders.
Ironically, those opinion leaders recommending gold are fundamentally correct—they truly see gold as a tool against inflation. Had the interviewees purchased according to spot prices and held onto it, they would be wealthier today.
But the reality is, their judgments have been distorted, exploited.
免责声明：本文章仅代表作者个人观点，不代表本平台的立场和观点。本文章仅供信息分享，不构成对任何人的任何投资建议。用户与作者之间的任何争议，与本平台无关。如网页中刊载的文章或图片涉及侵权，请提供相关的权利证明和身份证明发送邮件到support@aicoin.com，本平台相关工作人员将会进行核查。
