One Ticket Multi-Chain: Anthropic's Listing Reflects the "Fragmentation" Dilemma of Tokenized Assets

CN
14 minutes ago
What exactly are investors buying, stocks or price exposure?

Written by: Murtuza Merchant, Forbes

Translated by: Saoirse, Foresight News

Anthropic's landing on Nasdaq has exposed a tricky dilemma in the field of tokenized assets: the tokenized products corresponding to its stock are dispersed across multiple blockchains, while the New York Stock Exchange has chosen to build its own platform relying on Avalanche. Investors urgently need to clarify the differences in underlying public chains, specify the trading venues for assets, the ease of liquidity, and the supporting security mechanisms.

Anthropic's Listing Reflects the Competitive Landscape of the Blockchain Track

Anthropic has the stock code ANT and was listed on Nasdaq at 12:00 AM Beijing time on November 20, with an issue price of $83, raising approximately $81 billion, prompting major cryptocurrency trading platforms to quickly follow suit.

Ondo Finance has launched a token, ANTon, to track the price of this stock for qualified investors outside the United States; Backpack Securities has issued tokenized stocks on the Solana chain; related tokens xStocks and bStocks have launched on BNB Chain... In most cases, token holders only have exposure to the price fluctuations and do not hold the native Anthrop stock directly.

Not all companies endorse this model. Recently, JPMorgan, Microsoft, and many leading blue-chip companies have expressed their opposition to the unauthorized private tokenization of their own stocks.

Wall Street's Layout of Tokenized Assets: What Lies Ahead?

Major institutions have adopted different technological choices. On November 9, the NYSE selected Avalanche as the underlying ledger for its all-weather tokenized securities trading platform, which plans to officially launch after approval this quarter.

The platform also supports the issuance of securities products from other public chains. The NYSE's parent company, Intercontinental Exchange (ICE), will collaborate with cryptocurrency exchange OKX to launch another independent tokenized stock trading market on November 23. On November 19, Ant Group launched a settlement system for trading and clearing tokenized deposits and tokenized money market funds, with DBS Bank and Franklin Templeton participating as the first trial institutions.

Ethereum Still Ranks First, but Market Share Continues to Decline

Ethereum remains the current mainstream carrier. According to RWA.xyz data, approximately $46 billion in real asset tokens are distributed across more than 30 public chains, with Ethereum carrying around $22 billion, although its share is gradually declining.

A report jointly released by Allium and Stellar shows that as of September 30, the size of tokenized assets on the Stellar chain has increased to $4.12 billion, with market share rising from 4.9% during the same period last year to 12.7%, with Paris asset management firm Spiko being the main source of funds in this ecosystem.

What Are the Core Considerations for Institutions Choosing Public Chains?

The evaluation logic of institutions has significantly changed compared to several years ago. Raja Chakravorti, Chief Business Officer of the Stellar Development Foundation, stated: “Three years ago, the industry focused on the legality of the model; then shifted to system security. Now institutions prioritize the timeliness of going live and the richness of participants in the ecosystem.”

“Compliance control, cost, and transaction speed are the basic thresholds for public chains to enter the candidate list. The final decision depends on counterparties: which institutions are willing to accept this fund as collateral, which custodial wallets are compatible, and what clearing partners are available.” Most major asset management institutions will issue products on multiple public chains simultaneously, observing which chain can accumulate real liquidity.

Matt Mudano, founder and CEO of full-stack on-chain bank Arch Network, holds a different view. He believes that currently implemented institutional orders mostly flow to those public chains that completed resource accumulation and team maturity in the early stages of the crypto cycle, capable of undertaking custom development and long-term pilot projects for institutions. “This is more about business-level victories, not the final conclusion given by the market.” As related technologies gradually standardize, he predicts that issuers will follow distribution channels, prioritizing public chains that customers are already using.

Liquidity is of utmost importance. Daniil Kozin, CEO of crypto market maker EasyMM, stated: “Funds will congregate towards places where users and liquidity are concentrated.” When banks choose a public chain, they value the resources of buyers, custodians, and market makers within the ecosystem, as well as the underlying security architecture that has been validated over time, which is also a key reason Ethereum continues to lead. Currently, all public chains supporting tokenization business open access for holders and token freeze rights to issuers; “compliance is often not the decisive factor in selecting a public chain.”

Should Blockchains Have Native Compliance Control Capabilities?

Regulated issuers need to have investor qualification verification, token freezing, and asset recovery capabilities. Some public chains (such as Stellar) directly embed this control mechanism into the underlying protocol; in the Ethereum ecosystem, related capabilities are realized by issuers through custom smart contracts. Statistics from Allium show that as of September 30, over the past 12 months, issuers on the Stellar chain have completed a total of 7,050 holder qualification verifications and clearance operations, initiating 11 asset recovery actions. Franklin Templeton has also used this native tool to complete 372 investor qualification reviews for its BENJI money market fund.

Chakravorti mentioned: “Regulators focus on two core points: responsible parties and whether related assets can be halted after risks occur.” The native built-in controls mean that compliance teams only need to review a unified set of rules without auditing each product's custom contract individually.

However, Mudano believes the direction of the discussion is misplaced: “The core is not about where the freezing function is implemented but whether the underlying architecture of this chain can adapt to business scenarios.” Institutions also need a risk disposal mechanism to cope with significant unforeseen risks. “After the $1.4 billion theft incident at Bybit, Ethereum developers and the community rejected the on-chain rollback proposal. This aligns with Ethereum's design philosophy, but it constitutes a risk for institutions that underwrite the assets.”

Control mechanisms also come with costs. Kozin indicated that for licensed issuers, the negative impact of control is concentrated at the transaction end. Each added layer of access restrictions reduces the trading platforms and market makers that can undertake quotes. Therefore, tokens with strict control typically have weak market depth. He believes that public chains like Stellar, which natively integrate control modules, can reduce banks' compliance review costs; however, solutions relying on smart contracts for control require redeployment of contracts each time they migrate to a new chain.

Is Wall Street Really Using Public Chains?

Many industry insiders question this premise. Omid Malekan, a part-time professor at Columbia Business School, stated: “The vast majority of Wall Street institutions have not truly adopted permissionless public chains.”

In his view, many of the networks used by institutions are only nominally classified as public chains. He judges that the NYSE is most likely using a private subnet of Avalanche, and Ava Labs has also defined this architecture as "exclusive infrastructure."

Malekan believes that the motivation for choosing a private subnet does not stem from compliance pressure. Institutions like BlackRock and Franklin Templeton have already issued permissioned tokens on permissionless public chains. The shift to private networks is fundamentally an effort by leading intermediary institutions to retain their industry barriers and delay the disruption of existing business models.

Eswar Prasad, a professor of trade policy at Cornell University, has also expressed similar concerns: “If assets issued and traded on public chains are subject to highly centralized control, it deviates from the original intention of decentralizing finance on public chains.” The boundary between public and private chains is increasingly blurring.

Malekan points out in his paper that the core value of public chains – accessing the DeFi ecosystem and real-time settlement – can only be realized if the issuer does not arbitrarily intervene in the state of the tokens. Currently, no issuer has achieved this, but he believes that in the long run, the market will favor participants that prioritize autonomy.

Will Multi-Chain Distribution of Assets Spawn New Risks?

The initial goal of tokenization was to solve the fragmentation problem of traditional financial markets, and now assets are instead dispersed across dozens of different public chains.

Prasad warns that as banks compete to put Wall Street assets on-chain, the distribution of assets across multiple chains may cause liquidity fragmentation: increased difficulty in price discovery, expanded arbitrage opportunities, and intensified asset volatility. Emerging niche public chains may still face technical, governance, and liquidity risks that mature public chains (such as Ethereum) have already resolved.

Market makers are the first to feel this fragmentation. For instance, in the case of the BlackRock BUIDL fund, products are simultaneously deployed on Ethereum, Solana, BNB Chain, and other chains. Each additional chain splits the existing buyer community, thinning the order book depth, while market makers must continuously provide bilateral quotes across all chains, Kozin explained.

In relevant research, Malekan pointed out that assets on niche public chains carry higher counterparty risk, clearing risk, and operational risk. He predicts that in the long run, the market will only retain a few public chains: “Beyond decentralization, blockchains do not have significant advantages in other dimensions. If you discard decentralization, it becomes akin to a database without regulatory constraints, with extremely high counterparty risk.”

Chakravorti predicts that the track will form a multi-competitive landscape: “There have always been multiple settlement channels in payments and capital markets, and this will not change after migrating on-chain.” Mudano predicts that while the asset issuance side will remain decentralized, clearing businesses will converge to a few dedicated ledgers, consistent with traditional financial market logic: numerous issuers, but only a few clearing institutions. Kozin also believes that liquidity will concentrate on a few public chains. Many public chains designed specifically for tokenized assets will find it difficult to capture existing users from Ethereum and Solana, with Canton being an exception designed for banking privacy needs.

Investors Should Clarify These Issues Before Buying Tokenized Assets

For tokenized assets (including the recent Anthropic-related token products), the underlying public chain is no longer a trivial technical detail.

Investors need to confirm: whether they directly hold the underlying asset or just get price tracking exposure; whether the tokens can serve as collateral and if they can be transferred across borders; and which parties have the authority to freeze the tokens or reverse abnormal transactions.

The most basic issue is the exit channel. Kozin advises: “Make sure to confirm the selling channels.” If there is a lack of market makers on a chain, the transaction price of such tokenized stocks may deviate significantly from the real stock price, or even cannot be completed; for corresponding fund products, it's essential to confirm if the redemption path is smooth.

At the same time, it's necessary to verify the traceability of transaction records. Malekan stated: “If it is not a truly public network, we cannot verify the real transaction volume.”

免责声明:本文章仅代表作者个人观点,不代表本平台的立场和观点。本文章仅供信息分享,不构成对任何人的任何投资建议。用户与作者之间的任何争议,与本平台无关。如网页中刊载的文章或图片涉及侵权,请提供相关的权利证明和身份证明发送邮件到support@aicoin.com,本平台相关工作人员将会进行核查。

Share To
APP

X

Telegram

Facebook

Reddit

CopyLink