
John E Deaton|Aug 30, 2025 18:04
Mark is šÆ correct when it comes to how fucked up our system is related to drug pricing and the 3 PBMs that control it all.
We MUST reform our healthcare system and IMO, the very first step is ELIMINATING PBMs!
For those that donāt know, PBMs sit between drug manufacturers, insurers, pharmacies, and patients, and theyāve grown so powerful that they control which drugs are covered, how much people pay, and what pharmacies get reimbursed. 3 PBMs control 80-90% of all prescriptions in America.
These 3 PBMs negotiate rebates from drugmakers, but the savings donāt reach patients.
We engage in spread pricing - where they charge insurers/employers one price and reimburse pharmacies at a lower one - keeping the difference for themselves. Itās a Mafia-like business model.
PBMs also decide which drugs are āpreferred,ā sometimes pushing patients to more expensive medications because the rebates are higher.
I have watched Independent pharmacies in MA get squeezed so hard theyāre forced to close. Often times these independent pharmacies operate in underserved communities like Dorchester or Roxbury. I interviewed an owner of an independent pharmacy and he was literally getting reimbursed under his costs. Heās trying to survive (itās been a family business for 50 years) but what business can survive if you routinely get reimbursed less than your costs? The 3 PBMs are doing this intentionally and itās driving closures. Some of these independent community pharmacies deliver life-saving drugs to their customers because their customers donāt drive and itās physically too much for them to try and catch public transportation and they certainly canāt afford to take an Uber.
Hereās how we get rid of PBMs:
1. Ban spread pricing and require PBMs to pass 100% of rebates and discounts to patients or insurers.
2. Require transparency. Force PBMs to disclose what they negotiate and where the money flows. We should be able to compare the price of drugs the same way we compare prices for microwaves, refrigerators, cars watches or any other consumer product.
3. End rebate schemes and move toward fixed-fee payments for PBM services instead of percentage-based rebates.
4. Ban gag clauses so pharmacists can tell patients when cash pay is cheaper than insurance.
5. Federal regulations enacted treating PBMs like utilities and thus, subject to price oversight.
6. Facilitate competition. The 3 PBMs control 80-90% of all prescriptions. If we eliminate their stranglehold it will allow more competition like direct-to-consumer pharmacy models like @costplusdrugs that sell medications at transparent markups (cost + 15%). Competition drives prices down. Nothing is more American than facilitating that!(John E Deaton)
Timeline